Best Plastic Free Coffee Maker Reviews – Top 6 Picks (2018)

If you’ve heard alarming things about the impact of plastics on health, you might be considering a plastic free brewer.

We’ll examine what to look for as you make your choice. And we’ll check out six very different options to find the best plastic free coffee maker for you.

Our Top Recommended

Coffee Gator Pour Over Brewer – Unlock Flavor with Paperless Filter and Carafe – 27floz

Why buy a plastic free coffee maker?

plastic free coffee maker

The manufacture of plastics from the 1950s onwards changed the way we live our lives. Cheap and lightweight, they brought many benefits. But in recent years there’s been increasing concern that some kinds of plastics can harm human health.

The most well-known suspect is a substance called Bisphenol-A, or BPA. Until 2008 it was widely used in plastic products for babies and toddlers, such as drinking bottles and cups.

But then came a study suggesting it could seep into the body when used as containers for food and drink. Possible side effects were identified in relation to the brain and heart. It was even linked with cancer.

It’s for this reason that you’ll find many manufacturers now state their products are BPA-free.

But it’s worth remembering that there’s no conclusive link between BPA and health problems in humans. The majority of research has looked at animals.

The few studies using human data have produced inconclusive – and sometimes contradictory – results (1). This YouTube video provides a good overview of the findings.

And whilst BPA has grabbed the headlines, the verdict is also out on other plastics sometimes used in its place.

Researchers at Kings College London looked at six alternatives used in containers labeled BPA-free. They looked specifically at hormone levels associated with breast cancer. The findings were surprising. Some of the substances had a stronger effect than the BPA they replaced.

At this point, you might be wondering what you’re supposed to do to reduce your risk. It’s worth repeating: there’s no conclusive link between plastic containers and human health problems. But if you’d rather be safe than sorry, steer clear of plastic altogether.

And there are other advantages of going plastic-free.

The first is the environmental impact. Plastics degrade very slowly. That means when they’re no longer needed, they’re a real problem for the environment.

Stick them in the landfill and they’ll leach chemicals into the soil. And the impact on the oceans is arguably even worse.

If that doesn’t convince you, think of the taste. Reviewers of coffee makers complain time after time about plasticky flavors in their brew. Ditch the plastic and enjoy a cleaner taste.

Convinced? Here’s how to go about it.

What are the alternatives to plastic?

plastic free coffee maker reviews

As any coffee lover knows, there’s an enormous range of coffee makers out there. They come in different shapes, sizes and price points. And with a little careful hunting you can find plenty of plastic free options.

Look for machines made of glass or stainless steel. Glass versions will usually be easier to clean too. The glass will be toughened to withstand high temperatures, so most will cope with a cycle in the dishwasher.

Remember that a machine that looks as if it’s made of stainless steel may have plastic components. Don’t be fooled by a smart metal case – look at what’s going on inside.

Most important of all, consider the parts that will come into contact with the coffee and hot water.

What kind of brewer?

plastic free moka pot

When it comes to choosing a plastic free option, most of the questions to consider are the same as for any other coffee maker.

How much coffee do you want to brew at once? Do you want any extra gadgets? And of course, how much are you prepared to pay?

But it’s far easier to find plastic free versions of some styles of coffee maker than others.

The good news is that they needn’t be expensive. In fact, it’s usually the simpler types of coffee machine that don’t incorporate plastic parts.

And because they use materials like glass, copper and stainless steel instead, they’re often rather beautiful.

The downside is that machines with more bells and whistles almost always use plastic. If you want a super automatic espresso maker that’s plastic free – well, good luck. We haven’t found a single version that doesn’t use a plastic brew group.

The same goes for single cup coffee makers. Even beauties like the Nespresso KitchenAid, made in die-cast metal, have plastic components.

With simpler options like French presses, Moka pots, or pour over coffee makers, on the other hand, there’s more choice. Check out our reviews for some possibilities.

The Best Plastic Free Coffee Maker Reviews of 2018


1. Coffee Gator Pour Over Brewer (Our Top Recommended)

Coffee Gator Pour Over Brewer – Unlock Flavor with Paperless Filter and Carafe – 27floz

Coffee makers don’t come much simpler than this pour over brewer from Coffee Gator. Consisting of a glass brewer and a stainless steel filter, its elegant design looks good too. And you can buy one for less than the price of ten coffees at an artisan café.

The carafe is labeled BPA-free, but we’re reliably assured it’s made of glass. So you don’t need to worry that you’re getting other plastic nasties instead. Of course, that does mean you’ll have be careful with it. It won’t survive being dropped on the floor!

The carafe has a gauge and will hold up to six cups. Unless you have a huge household all wanting coffee at once, that should be enough. Remember, this is glass, so the coffee won’t stay warm or fresh for long.

The stainless steel filter is one of the best things about this brewer. There are none of the unwanted flavors you can get with paper versions. You won’t have to buy replacements. And its kind to the environment.

What I Like

  • Simple and stylish
  • Excellent stainless steel filter
  • Useful gauge on carafe

What I Didn't Like

  • The carafe won’t survive a fall
  • It’s pour-over – so it will take a bit of time to brew

2. Chemex Classic Series, Pour Over Glass Coffeemaker

Chemex Classic Series, Pour-over Glass Coffeemaker, 3-cup - Exclusive Packaging

The classic Chemex is a well-known option for pour over coffee. And it’s plastic free.

The carafe here is made of borosilicate glass, which means it’s tougher than standard. If you want to, you’ll be able to place it directly on your glass or gas stovetop to keep warm. If you’ve got electric coils, you’ll need to buy a separate stand.

Personally, we’d avoid placing the carafe on the stove. Even at gentle temperatures, the coffee will keep brewing and will end up bitter.

The Chemex comes in a range of sizes, from three to ten cup capacity. Buy one large enough to hold the amount you’ll drink straight away, and make another batch fresh when you want it. Yes, it will take more time, but it’s worth it for the flavor.

There’s no gauge on the side, but if you’re good at estimating volumes that might not be a problem. And we think the unadorned glass gives a really elegant look.

You’ll need paper filters for this one. Rinse them under running water before use to avoid a paper flavor transferring to your drink.

What I Like

  • Clean, elegant lines
  • Toughened borosilicate glass for a durable carafe

What I Didn't Like

  • No gauge on the carafe
  • You’ll need to buy separate filters

3. Secura Stainless Steel French Press Coffee Maker

Secura Stainless Steel French Press Coffee Maker 18/10 Bonus Stainless Steel Screen (1000ML)

Beware when searching for plastic free French presses – they’re not all as innocent as they first appear. Even those with stainless steel handles can have plastic strainers at the spout. This version by Secura, though, is made entirely of high grade 18/10 stainless steel.

It looks a bit more like a coffee pot than a traditional French Press. Its double-walled construction makes the carafe exceptionally durable, and it will keep coffee steaming hot for 20 to 30 minutes.

There’s a three-layer stainless steel filter so you won’t end up with grounds in your cup. You can take the assembly apart when it comes to cleaning. What’s more, every last component can be put into the dishwasher.

Its available in two different sizes, holding either 34 or 50 ounces of coffee. It’s built to last, and you won’t have to buy any filters. And as with all French presses, it’s very easy to use. What’s not to love?

What I Like

  • High-quality stainless steel construction
  • The carafe is durable and well insulated
  • Very easy to clean

What I Didn't Like

  • Not as attractive as some other French presses

4. Cuisinox Roma Stainless Steel Stovetop Moka Espresso Maker

Cuisinox Roma 6-cup Stainless Steel Stovetop Moka Espresso Maker

The Cuisinox Roma is pricier than many other Moka pots – but we think it’s worth it.

First up, it’s completely plastic free. And unlike some other Moka pots, it doesn’t contain aluminum either. The whole thing is made of 18/10 stainless steel.

It’s an elegant thing too, with a highly polished finish that will look great in your kitchen. Its induction base makes it suitable for use with any kind of hob.

Avoid problems with an uncomfortably hot handle by pre-heating the water before you put it on the stove. You’ll get a better flavor too.

There’s a rubber gasket, which creates the airtight seal needed for the pressure to build inside the pot. It lasts well, but you’ll also get a spare delivered with your coffee pot. It comes with a “reducer” too for when you want to brew smaller quantities of coffee.

The only downside here is the deep ridge that circles the outer edge of the reservoir. Coffee grounds will collect there and can be a bit of a pain to clean.

And although you can put the pot into the dishwasher now and again, you’ll risk damaging that polished surface.

What I Like

  • Superior Moka pot free from both plastic and aluminum
  • High performing gasket and comes with a spare
  • Reducer lets you brew smaller amounts

What I Didn't Like

  • Handle may get hot
  • Not the easiest to clean

5. Yama Silverton Hot or Cold Coffee Dripper, Copper/Wood

Yama Silverton Hot or Cold Coffee Dripper, Copper/Wood 18 oz. by Yama Glass

If you’re looking for a real statement piece for your kitchen, check out the Yama Silverton. What can we say? This is one fantastic looking coffee maker.

The dripper is suspended above the carafe by a single copper arm, with a matching spigot at the bottom. The whole thing stands on a polished wooden base. It looks like the kind of gadget you’d find in a nineteenth-century laboratory.

It’s made of toughened borosilicate glass – just as well, because you do not want to break something this beautiful. It will serve four to six people, and works just as well for cold brew or tea as for drip coffee.

It comes with a stainless steel filter cone, but you’ll have to buy paper filters. Rinse them first for a better flavor.

It isn’t the easiest thing in the world to use – but let’s face it, that’s not the point. Have fun experimenting while you show off its sculptural beauty to your friends.

What I Like

  • Unique appearance makes this a real conversation piece
  • Works just as well for tea or cold brew

What I Didn't Like

  • Takes some experimentation to get the best results

6. Diguo Belgian Luxury Royal Family Balance Siphon Coffee Maker

Diguo Belgian/Belgium Luxury Royal Family Balance Siphon/Syphon Coffee Maker. Elegant Double Ridged Fulcrum with Tee handle (Stylish Black & Silver)

If you’ve never come across a siphon coffee maker before, this offering from Diguo might come as a shock.

If you want a quick, convenient cup of coffee, stop reading now. You’ll need to practice using it, and it will take a while to make your drink. But if you want something to impress your guests at the end of a dinner party, you’ll be hard pressed to find a better option.

The eighteenth-century design uses gravity, vacuum and vapor pressures to extract the flavor from the coffee. You’ll need to supply your own fuel to make it work. Half-fill the spirit burner bottle with denatured alcohol, and use the smokeless version to avoid an indoor barbecue!

The materials here are borosilicate glass, wood, stainless steel and medical grade silicon for the seals. It comes with a cloth filter that can be washed and reused.  

What I Like

  • The whole set-up looks amazing. This is coffee-making as a spectator sport.

What I Didn't Like

  • It will take time and practice to get good results
  • You’ll need to buy denatured alcohol to fuel it.

Ready to buy?

We hope you’ve enjoyed our round-up of plastic free coffee makers.

There’s a huge amount of choice out there, covering all kind of coffee styles.

Our favorite is the Coffee Gator Pour Over Brewer. It’s inexpensive, easy to get great results, and you need never buy another filter.

Whatever option you choose, you’ll be reducing plastic use – and that’s great for both the environment and your health.

My name is Kathy Gallo, Editor of Daily Cupo, a Coffee buff. The guide you find here is designed exactly for you, and it is our hope that you find it not only interesting but also actionable.

Related Post

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.